The environmental effects of cryptocurrency mining have been discussed at length by activists and concerned investors. Mining is well-recognized as a process that results in a large carbon footprint due to the massive amount of power that goes into helping the gadgets function. The cooling systems also use energy, so mining has started to be associated with a carbon footprint roughly equivalent to that of smaller countries. In the context of the worsening of global warming, this is seriously worrying news, especially since cryptocurrencies are expected to continue growing. The Ethereum prediction for 2024 is that the coin will reach new heights, an event that will naturally boost engagement rates and the number of transactions investors perform.
With all that in mind, the question arises of whether there is an actual way to make cryptocurrencies more sustainable. The short answer is yes, but as with anything related to the world of cryptocurrencies, implementation can be quite difficult, and there are several possible challenges ahead.
Renewable energy
Much of the energy that goes into powering the crypto mining systems comes from non-renewable sources, meaning that it directly contributes to the greenhouse effect, the process through which heat is trapped very close to the Earth and which causes the rising temperatures the entire planet is struggling with. Research shows that 67% of the electricity used during mining comes from fossil fuel sources, with coal making up 45% of that total amount. Oil, coal, and natural gas formed during prehistoric times as a result of the death and decay of mostly algae and other plant matter that sank to the seafloor, mixed with sediments, and was buried under layers of rock.
This occurred over millions of years due to high temperatures and high pressure, and if they keep being used at the current rate, research estimates that most of the fossil fuels will be entirely depleted by the 2060s, with coal possibly able to endure for half a century more. And while the formation process still occurs today, it would take millions of years just as it did in the past. This incredibly lengthy process is what makes these resources non-renewable, since although they can replenish the timeframe in which they do is so much higher than the human lifespan that it isn’t even worth considering.
The first step in lowering the carbon footprint would be for the industry to switch to renewable sources. The transition will take time and require changes to the infrastructure, but it is most definitely worth it, given the potential impact. All miners should focus on the sources that are most available in their area, whether that includes solar energy, wind or hydropower, or geothermal energy. Bhutan has recently become a shining example in this area, as the country was revealed to be the home of extensive mining facilities that rely on geothermal energy to operate.
Traditional systems
Although crypto and traditional finance are understood to be entirely separate from one another, they are frequently compared to each other in terms of speed, reliability, and the features they can provide for the users. Naturally, their sustainability and energy consumption were compared as well, most recently in a 2023 study published by the academic journal Ecological Economics. Researchers from the IMP showed estimates that the global payment system uses up roughly 0.2% of the global electricity consumption. This is a rough equivalent of the consumption levels of countries like Bangladesh or Portugal.
Cryptocurrencies are naturally considerably higher, and while a transaction using the classic credit card uses approximately 0.001kWh, Bitcoin consumes a whopping 500kWh, with some climbing up to 851.77kWh. This number is roughly equivalent to about a month of usage in the average American household. However, some researchers have pointed out that it’s not really fair to compare transactions in this manner, as not all crypto transactions are created equal. The use of proof-of-work protocols compared to proof-of-stake yields a higher carbon footprint, so the blockchains that use PoS are naturally more sustainable.
Batching, layer2 solutions, and other features located on the decentralized ledger also change the outcome, as they allow more payments to be processed or make the transactions more scalable so that they can be dealt with more rapidly. The number of payments is often not directly correlated with the number of on-chain transactions, so in 2022, for instance, Bitcoin had 100 million transactions every year, resulting in 250 million separate payments.
Water footprint
The water footprint shows the extent of water people consume. Data from 2023 shows that the average water footprint of cryptocurrencies is around 1,600 gigalitres. The quantity comes from both on-site water usage, as well as the indirect consumption resulting from electricity generation. What’s concerning is that water consumption appears to be on an ascending path in the sector, increasing by a hefty 166% in the span of just one year between 2020 and 2021.
The primary solution would be to avoid focusing on using freshwater for cooling or employ immersion cooling. This practice involves complete server submersion in a dielectric, an insulating material, or a poor conductor of electrical current. It increases capacitance and lowers electric field strength so that the same charge is obtained at a lower voltage. Liquid dielectrics can be used as well, with purified water, transformer oil, and perfluorocarbons being some of the most known, but there’s also the option of silicone oil, although it is typically pricier.
Electronic waste
The issue of unrecycled waste is a serious problem for the environment, as the heaps and piles of trash accumulating in landfills contribute to the rise of global greenhouse gas emissions. Special computing hardware is necessary for crypto mining, and it cannot be employed in other uses outside of coin minting. The network hashrate has been growing over the years, so a device now has an average lifespan of as little over a year before it becomes obsolete and unprofitable and has to be replaced with a newer model. This results in considerable electronic waste, with estimates of 30,000 tons every year, a number comparable to the tech equipment waste produced by the Netherlands. However, other researchers have claimed that the average lifespan of mining devices is closer to four or five years.
The crypto market has taken the financial world by storm, but its enduring environmental impact has stained its reputation. Moving forward, the sector must find ways to reduce its carbon footprint to provide users with a more sustainable experience so that cryptocurrencies can contribute to the fight against climate change.